Surface marks show where New Reward checks visibility. They are not partner badges or outcome guarantees.

Compare

AI visibility platform vs SEO agency: which do you need?

Buyers usually frame this as a tool-versus-agency decision: pay tool money for a dashboard and do the work yourself, or pay agency money and trust the monthly report. Both framings hide the same gap — proof.

What platforms give you

Measurement breadth and speed: scores, prompt tracking, citation analysis, alerts. What they don't give you is hands — their own docs say they recommend rather than execute. The dashboard's to-do list lands on your team's backlog.

What agencies give you

Hands and judgment. Utah's strong shops — 97th Floor, Big Leap, Avalaunch, Upward Engine — all now market AI-search services and genuinely ship content, technical, and authority work. The proof, though, arrives as audits, case studies, and monthly KPI reports: relationship-level evidence, not action-level evidence.

The third option: a proof loop

New Reward sits between the two: platform-style scoring of Google and AI-answer visibility, agency-style shipped fixes, and the piece neither side shows — per-action, inspectable evidence connecting the fix to the gap it closed.

The players, from their own pages

97th Floor

Agency execution

Dedicated AI SEO/GEO practice covering ChatGPT, AI Overviews, Perplexity, Gemini, and Claude — "content, structure and citations: the three levers" — plus a free AI Overview Presence Audit.

How you buy
Agency engagement; campaigns scoped with a dedicated team.
Best fit
Brands ready for a full agency engagement that want a 20-year Utah agency with Fortune 500 references doing the work.

Sources: 97thfloor.com · 97thfloor.com

Big Leap

Agency execution

An "AI SEO" service framed as GEO for ChatGPT Search, Google AI Overviews, Perplexity, and Claude, with LLM optimization, entity mapping, and structured data.

How you buy
Agency retainer covering SEO, content, and RevOps.
Best fit
Brands that want a long-tenured relationship agency covering SEO, content, and RevOps under one retainer.

Sources: bigleap.com

Avalaunch Media

Agency execution

A Generative AI Optimization (GEO/LLMO) service built around "the great uncoupling" — ensuring brands are "accurately represented" in ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude, and Perplexity.

How you buy
Agency engagement led by a fractional CMO.
Best fit
Companies that want strategy leadership (a fractional CMO) bundled with creative and media execution.

Sources: avalaunchmedia.com

Upward Engine (formerly SEO Werkz)

Agency execution

A dedicated "AI SEO & GEO Agency" page claiming Answer Engine Optimization expertise and visibility on ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, and Google AI Mode.

How you buy
Month-to-month agency engagement; no long-term contracts.
Best fit
Utah SMBs that want a no-contract local agency with recognizable local client names.

Sources: upwardengine.com · upwardengine.com

Boostability

Partner fulfillment

The "Be Found Framework — our AI-Ready SEO system," refreshed May 2026 to target AI Overviews and voice by "being the most accurate answer available"; AI framed as supportive to traditional SEO.

How you buy
Productized packages, sold direct or white-label through partner agencies.
Best fit
SMBs that want a productized SEO package, and agencies that need white-label fulfillment.

Sources: boostability.com · boostability.com

Common questions

Asked before choosing.

When is an SEO agency the right choice?

When you need strategy leadership and a broad execution team — creative, PR, paid media — under one retainer, and you're comfortable evaluating the work through monthly reporting and the relationship.

When is a visibility platform enough?

When you have an in-house team with capacity to execute and you mainly need measurement: which prompts, which surfaces, which competitors, which gaps.

Where does New Reward fit?

New Reward runs a proof loop. A visibility score finds the gap across Google and AI answers. An approved action ships. The result is inspectable evidence, not a dashboard recommendation or a monthly report you have to take on trust.

How this comparison is sourced Competitor details come from their own public pages, with sources linked on each comparison. Current verification is pending a fresh source check; confirm time-sensitive product and buying details directly with each vendor. New Reward claims here describe how the product works, not outcome guarantees.

Decide with your own data

Run the comparison on your brand.

Get the free score in ~2 min, request the free audit for ranked gaps, or book the demo and watch the proof loop run end to end.