Compare

Every tool shows a dashboard. Ask who ships the fix.

These comparisons are built from each competitor's own public pages — what they measure, how they sell, and how deep their execution really goes. Where they're the better choice, the page says so.

Comparison guides

Start from the decision you're actually making.

Category guide

AI visibility tools compared: who actually ships the fix?

An honest comparison of AI visibility tools — Semrush, Profound, Scrunch AI, Yext, BrightEdge — by what they measure, how you buy them, and whether anyone ships the fix.

Read the comparison

Category guide

Best AI visibility tools for tracking your brand in ChatGPT and Perplexity

Compare AI visibility tools to track how your brand appears in ChatGPT and Perplexity: OtterlyAI, Semrush, Ahrefs Brand Radar, Peec AI, and New Reward's proof loop.

Read the comparison

Category guide

Top GEO platforms for brand presence in AI search engines

Compare GEO platforms for optimizing brand presence in AI search engines: Ahrefs Brand Radar, Semrush, OtterlyAI, Peec AI, and New Reward.

Read the comparison

Category guide

Tools to monitor and improve brand mentions in AI Overviews and generative search

Compare brand-monitoring tools for AI Overviews and generative search, and when to use New Reward to turn monitoring gaps into shipped fixes.

Read the comparison

Category guide

Otterly alternatives for tracking brand visibility in AI search

Compare Otterly alternatives for AI search visibility: Ahrefs Brand Radar, Semrush, Peec AI, and New Reward for execution-backed proof.

Read the comparison

Category guide

AI visibility platform vs SEO agency: which do you need?

Dashboards tell you what's broken; agencies do work you take on trust. An honest look at platforms vs SEO agencies for AI-era visibility — and the proof loop in between.

Read the comparison

Head to head

New Reward vs Semrush: recommendations vs shipped proof

Semrush's AI Visibility Toolkit measures and recommends; New Reward scores the same gaps, ships the fixes, and shows inspectable evidence. An honest comparison for buyers.

Read the comparison

Head to head

New Reward vs Ahrefs Brand Radar: AI visibility research vs shipped proof

Ahrefs Brand Radar finds brand mentions and AI citations. New Reward turns the same visibility gaps into approved fixes with inspectable evidence.

Read the comparison

Head to head

New Reward vs OtterlyAI: monitoring vs execution-backed evidence

OtterlyAI monitors AI search visibility across ChatGPT, Perplexity, and Google AI Overviews. New Reward ships the fixes and records evidence.

Read the comparison

Head to head

New Reward vs Peec AI: AI-search analytics vs shipped fixes

Peec AI gives marketers AI-search analytics, competitor benchmarks, and query-fanout insight. New Reward turns findings into shipped fixes with evidence.

Read the comparison

Head to head

New Reward vs Profound: enterprise dashboards vs the proof loop

Profound is the enterprise AI-visibility measurement leader. New Reward turns the same diagnosis into shipped fixes with inspectable evidence. An honest comparison.

Read the comparison

Head to head

New Reward vs Scrunch AI: a rendered layer vs fixing the real site

Scrunch AI monitors AI visibility and serves AI crawlers a machine-readable layer. New Reward ships approved fixes to your actual site with inspectable evidence.

Read the comparison

Head to head

New Reward vs Yext: listings sync vs whole-gap fixes

Yext Scout measures AI visibility at location scale and syncs listings through its network. New Reward ships whatever fix the gap needs, with inspectable evidence.

Read the comparison

The field at a glance

Ten competitors, by the two questions that matter.

Semrush

Self-serve platform

How you buy: Self-serve subscription; the enterprise tier is sales-led and quote-only.
Implementation depth: Recommendations; Semrush's own documentation states the toolkit provides "actionable recommendations" but does not execute changes.

Ahrefs Brand Radar

Self-serve platform

How you buy: Self-serve Ahrefs suite with Brand Radar access; larger teams can use Ahrefs' enterprise motion.
Implementation depth: Recommendations; Ahrefs shows what AI answers cite and where competitors are winning; execution remains with the user's SEO/content team.

OtterlyAI

Self-serve platform

How you buy: Self-serve monitoring product with broader agency and enterprise positioning.
Implementation depth: Recommendations; OtterlyAI monitors and reports where a brand appears or loses ground; the user's team still has to ship the fixes.

Peec AI

Self-serve platform

How you buy: Self-serve and agency-oriented plans, with broader team options available through the vendor.
Implementation depth: Recommendations; Peec AI gives teams strategic AI-search data and query-fanout insight; implementation still belongs to the customer or agency team.

Yext

Enterprise platform

How you buy: Sales-led; enterprise contracts via contact-sales only.
Implementation depth: Productized action; Execution is real but largely confined to listings and structured data inside Yext's publisher network; broader site and content fixes remain recommendations.

Profound

Enterprise platform

How you buy: Sales-led; access is demo-gated with custom quotes.
Implementation depth: Recommendations; Primarily analytics and insights. Newly marketed "Profound Agents" claim autonomous execution, but public pages do not show shipped-work evidence.

Scrunch AI

Self-serve platform

How you buy: Self-serve signup with a 7-day free trial; enterprise tier is custom.
Implementation depth: Recommendations; One productized action — the Agent Experience Platform serves an optimized parallel layer to AI crawlers — but fixes to the actual site remain recommendations.

BrightEdge

Enterprise platform

How you buy: Sales-led; quote-based annual contracts.
Implementation depth: Productized action; Autopilot automates template-level technical SEO (orphan pages, mobile issues, duplicate content) "without developer support"; AI Catalyst itself recommends rather than executes.

97th Floor

Utah agency

How you buy: Agency engagement; campaigns scoped with a dedicated team.
Implementation depth: Agency execution; Dedicated multi-disciplinary teams ship content, technical, and authority work; campaigns launch within two weeks of kickoff.

Big Leap

Utah agency

How you buy: Agency retainer covering SEO, content, and RevOps.
Implementation depth: Agency execution; Full content, technical, and digital-PR delivery plus revenue operations; no client-facing AI dashboard shown publicly.

Upward Engine (formerly SEO Werkz)

Utah agency

How you buy: Month-to-month agency engagement; no long-term contracts.
Implementation depth: Agency execution; Performs content, technical, and link work directly for clients.

Avalaunch Media

Utah agency

How you buy: Agency engagement led by a fractional CMO.
Implementation depth: Agency execution; Fractional CMOs set execution plans and in-house teams deliver technical, content, and authority work.

Boostability

SMB fulfillment

How you buy: Productized packages, sold direct or white-label through partner agencies.
Implementation depth: Partner fulfillment; Productized SMB packages delivered at scale, frequently as the unbranded execution engine behind other agencies.

Competitor	Category	How you buy	Implementation depth
Semrush	Self-serve platform	Self-serve subscription; the enterprise tier is sales-led and quote-only.	RecommendationsSemrush's own documentation states the toolkit provides "actionable recommendations" but does not execute changes.
Ahrefs Brand Radar	Self-serve platform	Self-serve Ahrefs suite with Brand Radar access; larger teams can use Ahrefs' enterprise motion.	RecommendationsAhrefs shows what AI answers cite and where competitors are winning; execution remains with the user's SEO/content team.
OtterlyAI	Self-serve platform	Self-serve monitoring product with broader agency and enterprise positioning.	RecommendationsOtterlyAI monitors and reports where a brand appears or loses ground; the user's team still has to ship the fixes.
Peec AI	Self-serve platform	Self-serve and agency-oriented plans, with broader team options available through the vendor.	RecommendationsPeec AI gives teams strategic AI-search data and query-fanout insight; implementation still belongs to the customer or agency team.
Yext	Enterprise platform	Sales-led; enterprise contracts via contact-sales only.	Productized actionExecution is real but largely confined to listings and structured data inside Yext's publisher network; broader site and content fixes remain recommendations.
Profound	Enterprise platform	Sales-led; access is demo-gated with custom quotes.	RecommendationsPrimarily analytics and insights. Newly marketed "Profound Agents" claim autonomous execution, but public pages do not show shipped-work evidence.
Scrunch AI	Self-serve platform	Self-serve signup with a 7-day free trial; enterprise tier is custom.	RecommendationsOne productized action — the Agent Experience Platform serves an optimized parallel layer to AI crawlers — but fixes to the actual site remain recommendations.
BrightEdge	Enterprise platform	Sales-led; quote-based annual contracts.	Productized actionAutopilot automates template-level technical SEO (orphan pages, mobile issues, duplicate content) "without developer support"; AI Catalyst itself recommends rather than executes.
97th Floor	Utah agency	Agency engagement; campaigns scoped with a dedicated team.	Agency executionDedicated multi-disciplinary teams ship content, technical, and authority work; campaigns launch within two weeks of kickoff.
Big Leap	Utah agency	Agency retainer covering SEO, content, and RevOps.	Agency executionFull content, technical, and digital-PR delivery plus revenue operations; no client-facing AI dashboard shown publicly.
Upward Engine (formerly SEO Werkz)	Utah agency	Month-to-month agency engagement; no long-term contracts.	Agency executionPerforms content, technical, and link work directly for clients.
Avalaunch Media	Utah agency	Agency engagement led by a fractional CMO.	Agency executionFractional CMOs set execution plans and in-house teams deliver technical, content, and authority work.
Boostability	SMB fulfillment	Productized packages, sold direct or white-label through partner agencies.	Partner fulfillmentProductized SMB packages delivered at scale, frequently as the unbranded execution engine behind other agencies.

How this data is sourced Competitor details come from their own public pages, with sources linked on each comparison. Current verification is pending a fresh source check; confirm time-sensitive product and buying details directly with each vendor.

See it on your own brand

The fastest comparison is your own score.

Run the free score to see how Google and AI answers treat your brand today, request the free audit for the ranked gaps, or book the demo to watch the proof loop end to end.

Get your AI-visibility score Book the AI-visibility demo